Bagel Street Grill - A Hidden Gem in Plainsboro, NJ

I went here for the first time maybe a year ago, it was far away but I heard good things. I moved and tried my local bagel place amf thought "this is good, but not as good as bagel Street", but in the back of my head thought we'll maybe I hyping it up. I went back recently, out of my way, and it was just that good. Best bagels around, worth going out of your way for. Good enough to get stuck in your head.

The bagels are fresh and the taste is predictable. Their jalapeno bagels are my favorite, and they work well with the cheddar cheese

Bagel was good... delicious. The workers... they looked tired. Don't blame them. The bagels tasted so good its because how hard they worked throughout the night. When you press on the bagel, you know the dough is done right. Wait until you put in your mouth.

Excellent Bagels. Tons of varieties. Very good sandwich and omlette options. Bulk pick up avaible. Opens early. Gets packed early mornings.

Best French toast bagels I've ever had and ever will have. Everything else is on point as well. Excellent food!

If you are in NJ and looking for English breakfast I do recommend this place. You got wide range of breads and different varieties of dishes one can think of in breakfast. Their service is pretty quick and clean.

They’ve got good bagels however they consistently mess up orders. For instance I went in on October 18th 2025 to get 2 breakfast burritos one with meat and one without. Plates were handed to us one labeled No meat upon eating it meat was found in the one labeled no meat. If you want bagels just get bagels. If you want an order correct go somewhere else or really make sure they heard you and are paying attention.

We ordered an Asiago bagel with egg and bacon, a lox bagel with cream cheese, tomato and lettuce, Law coffee and a cappuccino. Bagels themselves are tasty and the one with egg and bacon is pretty good especially for the price. The lox one is not so good, basically you pay $6 extra for some slices of lox that are not thicker than the tomato slices :)) Avoid that and also the cappuccino which tasted like hot thick sugary chocolate. Regular Law coffee with hazelnut flavor is good enough. About the store: the area is clean and service is fast and they have many customers. Will come back to this place!